This post is based on the episode with Matt Goldish who at the time of the recording was a professor at Ohio State University and a specialist in Jewish and European History, Messianism, and the Spanish Jews after the expulsion from Spain. He holds the Samuel M. and Esther Melton Chair in Jewish History. The topic of our discussion was his book The Sabbatean Prophets, The post was generated by AI but edited by a human.
Purchase The Sabbatean Prophets
In 1665, an extraordinary religious movement swept through Jewish communities across the Ottoman Empire and Europe.
Its followers believed that the long-awaited Messiah had finally arrived.
His name was Shabbetai Tzvi, a Jewish mystic from Smyrna, in what is now Izmir, Turkey.
People traveled enormous distances to see him. Rabbis and ordinary Jews became convinced that redemption was imminent. Letters announcing his messianic mission circulated across the Jewish world, while reports of prophecy, trances, and extraordinary religious experiences fueled the movement's rapid expansion.
Then, in 1666, Shabbetai Tzvi converted to Islam.
For many of his followers, the conversion was devastating. The man they believed would redeem the Jewish people had apparently abandoned Judaism.
But others reached a remarkable conclusion.
His conversion did not disprove his messianic mission. It was part of that mission.
In this episode of The Levantini Podcast, I speak with Professor Matt Goldish of Ohio State University, author of The Sabbatean Prophets, about one of the most extraordinary episodes in Jewish religious history.
We explore how the movement emerged, why it spread so quickly, the pivotal role of Nathan of Gaza, and how Sabbateanism continued to influence Jewish religious life long after its central figure had converted to Islam.
Who Was Shabbetai Tzvi?
Shabbetai Tzvi was born in Smyrna, a major commercial city of the Ottoman Empire, in the seventeenth century.
Goldish describes him as a member of the Romaniote Jewish world, associated with older Byzantine Jewish communities rather than the Sephardic population that had arrived following the expulsions from Spain.
He was deeply interested in Jewish mysticism and religious study.
Around 1648, according to the account Goldish reconstructs, Shabbetai began telling a small circle of acquaintances that he believed himself to be the Messiah.
At first, the claim attracted little attention.
For years, Shabbetai experienced periods of intense religious conviction alternating with periods in which his messianic identity seemed less certain.
Gershom Scholem, the pioneering historian of Jewish mysticism, famously interpreted this pattern in terms of bipolar disorder.
Goldish discusses that interpretation while acknowledging the inherent difficulties of reconstructing the psychological condition of a person who lived centuries ago.
Whatever the explanation for his changing behavior, Shabbetai's extraordinary religious personality became central to the movement that eventually developed around him.
But the transformation from an obscure mystic into a figure believed to be the Messiah required another person.
That person was Nathan of Gaza.
What Did Jews Expect the Messiah to Do?
To understand why Shabbetai's movement was so remarkable, we first discussed the history of Jewish messianic expectations.
The Hebrew word mashiach means 'anointed one.'
In familiar traditional formulations, the Messiah is a descendant of King David who will gather the Jewish exiles, restore Jewish sovereignty, rebuild the Temple in Jerusalem, and bring humanity to recognition of God.
But Goldish emphasizes that Jewish messianism has never consisted of a single unchanging set of expectations.
Different periods produced different models of redemption.
In the late Second Temple period, messianic hopes were often associated with political and military liberation.
Under Roman rule, some Jewish leaders were understood as potential liberators who might overthrow imperial domination.
Bar Kokhba, who led a major Jewish revolt against Rome in 132–135 CE, became one of the most prominent examples of a military figure associated with messianic expectations.
Other traditions emphasized spiritual transformation rather than military victory.
By the early modern period, Jewish messianic expectations were increasingly intertwined with Kabbalah, the mystical tradition that explored the hidden structure of divine reality.
Shabbetai Tzvi belonged primarily to this mystical world.
He was not a military commander promising to defeat the Ottoman Empire.
He was a charismatic religious figure whose followers interpreted his actions through elaborate mystical explanations.
Why Was the Seventeenth Century Ripe for a Messianic Movement?
Goldish argues that the Sabbatean movement cannot be understood simply by examining Shabbetai Tzvi's personality.
It emerged from a particular historical environment.
The seventeenth century was a period of political, economic, and social disruption across many parts of the world.
Historians sometimes describe this broader pattern as the 'general crisis of the seventeenth century.'
Jewish communities faced additional pressures.
The expulsion of Jews from Spain in 1492 and subsequent expulsions and religious pressures elsewhere in Europe had transformed Jewish communal life.
In the middle of the seventeenth century, the Khmelnytsky uprising and associated massacres devastated Jewish communities in parts of eastern Europe.
At the same time, increased mobility and changing economic circumstances gave some Jews greater freedom to move between communities and redefine their religious affiliations.
Goldish also points to uneven rabbinic authority.
Some Jewish communities retained powerful religious leadership.
In others, rabbis had difficulty enforcing decisions or maintaining communal unity.
This did not mean that rabbinic authority had disappeared everywhere.
But the religious world was sufficiently fragmented that a charismatic movement could challenge established leaders and spread rapidly across regional boundaries.
Shabbetai Tzvi's movement developed within this unstable environment.
The Conversos and the Search for a Jewish Redeemer
Another important part of the story involves the conversos.
Conversos were Jews, or descendants of Jews, who had converted to Christianity, often under pressure in Spain and Portugal.
Some later returned to Judaism.
Their descendants helped establish important Jewish communities in places such as Amsterdam, London, Hamburg, Livorno, and cities of the Ottoman Empire.
Goldish explains that these communities occupied an unusual religious position.
Some members had been raised as Christians and encountered Jewish communal life only later.
Their religious experiences therefore differed from those of Jews whose families had continuously practiced Judaism.
Messianic expectations were particularly important in some converso circles.
Goldish discusses the possibility that Christian ideas about a messianic savior influenced how some former conversos imagined Jewish redemption.
He also describes the special importance of Queen Esther.
Esther concealed her Jewish identity while living in the Persian royal court and ultimately helped save her people.
For some conversos, she became a model for their own situation: a Jewish figure whose concealed identity could serve a redemptive purpose.
This background later helped certain Sabbatean thinkers explain Shabbetai Tzvi's conversion to Islam.
One prominent example was Abraham Miguel Cardoso, a former converso who argued that the Messiah's own conversion could be understood through the experience of hidden Jewish identity.
Nathan of Gaza: The Prophet Who Made a Messiah
The decisive turning point came in 1665.
Shabbetai Tzvi was in Egypt, where he had been involved in collecting funds for Jewish communities in the Land of Israel.
He was again experiencing intense messianic convictions.
A prominent acquaintance recommended that he visit a young Kabbalist in Gaza named Nathan.
Nathan of Gaza was only about twenty-two years old.
Yet he had already developed a reputation for exceptional piety, asceticism, and mystical knowledge.
Goldish explains that people did not necessarily expect religious authorities of the period to function like modern counselors.
A respected mystical leader might instead be someone who fasted, prayed intensely, slept little, and appeared capable of perceiving the hidden condition of another person's soul.
Nathan was regarded as such a figure.
Shabbetai apparently hoped that Nathan would provide a tikkun, a spiritual remedy for his troubling religious experiences.
Instead, Nathan told him something entirely different.
He declared that Shabbetai really was the Messiah.
Goldish describes how Nathan's conviction reinforced Shabbetai's own messianic identity.
The relationship between the two men became one of the central forces behind the movement.
Shabbetai provided the charismatic messianic figure.
Nathan provided the prophetic authority that explained who Shabbetai was and what his appearance meant.
The Shavuot Prophecy of 1665
Goldish's book emphasizes an element of the Sabbatean movement that is sometimes overshadowed by Shabbetai himself.
The movement spread through prophecy.
During the festival of Shavuot in 1665, Nathan of Gaza reportedly experienced an extraordinary episode in the presence of other religious scholars.
According to accounts discussed by Goldish, Nathan collapsed and appeared to lose consciousness.
Those present feared that he had died.
Then a voice reportedly emerged from his mouth, proclaiming Shabbetai Tzvi to be the Messiah.
When Nathan recovered, he appeared not to remember what had happened.
The episode echoed an earlier mystical tradition associated with the sixteenth-century rabbi Joseph Karo.
Karo, best known as the author of the Shulchan Aruch, was also associated with accounts of a disembodied voice delivering revelations during religious study.
For Nathan's contemporaries, such precedents helped make the experience intelligible as a form of divine revelation.
Goldish argues that this prophetic spectacle was crucial.
People were not persuaded solely by a theological argument that Shabbetai was the Messiah.
They believed they had witnessed extraordinary evidence of divine intervention.
As those present traveled to other communities and described what they had seen, the movement began to spread.
Why Did Ordinary People Begin Prophesying?
The reported experiences were not confined to Nathan of Gaza.
Goldish describes how outbreaks of prophecy appeared in Jewish communities across the Ottoman Empire and eventually Europe.
People entered trances, experienced unusual bodily movements, or claimed to speak under the influence of a supernatural presence.
Some reported speaking in unfamiliar languages.
Women, young people, and other individuals who ordinarily held little religious authority could suddenly become the center of communal attention.
This was one of the movement's most disruptive features.
A rabbi's formal education and communal position were no longer the only sources of religious authority.
An ordinary person who appeared to be receiving a divine message could command an audience.
Goldish compares these events with possession and prophetic phenomena reported in contemporary Christian and Muslim communities.
He uses the concept of adorcism to describe practices intended to invite a spirit into a person, rather than expel one.
Such experiences were understood within a seventeenth-century religious culture in which supernatural intervention was taken seriously.
The historical sources establish that these episodes were reported and widely interpreted as prophetic.
They do not allow historians to determine that the experiences were supernatural in origin.
How Did the Sabbatean Movement Spread So Quickly?
The movement spread through a combination of personal testimony, religious networks, written correspondence, and charismatic encounters.
Nathan of Gaza circulated letters and theological writings explaining Shabbetai's messianic mission.
Other supporters developed their own interpretations.
Travelers carried news from one Jewish community to another.
People who had witnessed prophetic episodes described them to new audiences.
And reports of further revelations reinforced the growing conviction that something extraordinary was happening.
The movement also attracted attention outside Jewish communities.
Goldish discusses accounts written by Dutch and English observers in the Ottoman Empire, including ministers, diplomats, and commercial representatives.
Some Christian millenarians were particularly interested.
They believed that the return of Jews to the Land of Israel could be connected to the anticipated second coming of Christ.
They did not necessarily accept Shabbetai as the Jewish Messiah, but they sometimes viewed his movement as a possible sign of approaching redemption.
This outside attention helps explain why the historical record is unusually rich.
The Sabbatean movement was documented not only by Jewish believers and opponents but also by Christians who observed it from different perspectives.
Why Did Shabbetai Tzvi Break Jewish Religious Laws?
Shabbetai Tzvi became known for actions that violated established Jewish religious norms.
Goldish describes these as examples of antinomianism: behavior that challenges or rejects religious law.
One especially unusual episode involved Shabbetai arranging a marriage ceremony between himself and a Torah scroll.
Other actions also shocked contemporary rabbis.
Yet followers sometimes interpreted such behavior as evidence of his extraordinary religious status.
The logic was that the arrival of the Messiah might transform the meaning of religious commandments.
Acts that would normally be prohibited could be reinterpreted as part of a hidden mystical process.
Goldish emphasizes the flexibility of Kabbalistic symbolism.
Mystical interpretations could provide explanations for behavior that otherwise seemed impossible to reconcile with Jewish law.
This made the movement capable of absorbing contradictions.
Actions that might have discredited another religious leader could instead become evidence of Shabbetai's special mission.
What Happened When Shabbetai Tzvi Was Arrested?
As the movement expanded, Ottoman authorities became concerned about its possible political consequences.
Shabbetai traveled within the Ottoman Empire and was eventually arrested.
Goldish describes an unusual period of imprisonment in which Shabbetai was able to receive visitors and maintain an impressive following.
Supporters continued to travel to see him.
The prison did not immediately end his messianic reputation.
Eventually, however, Shabbetai came before Ottoman authorities who were far less willing to tolerate a potentially destabilizing religious movement.
The decisive moment came in 1666.
Faced with the threat of severe punishment, Shabbetai converted to Islam.
For a figure proclaimed as the redeemer of the Jewish people, the decision was extraordinary.
Rather than dying as a martyr, he publicly adopted the religion of the empire that held him.
Why Did Shabbetai Tzvi Convert to Islam?
Goldish describes Shabbetai's conversion as one of the most surprising moments in the history of Jewish messianism.
According to the account discussed in the interview, Shabbetai was warned that conversion offered a means of avoiding execution.
He accepted.
Goldish also places the event within the political and religious culture of the Ottoman court.
Conversion to Islam could bring individuals and groups more firmly under imperial authority.
But the available evidence does not allow us to reduce Shabbetai's decision to a single, certain motive.
Was he primarily trying to survive?
Did he believe that conversion had a mystical purpose?
Did his understanding of his own messianic role change?
The surviving evidence is contradictory.
Goldish emphasizes that Shabbetai's statements after conversion were inconsistent.
At times, he suggested that his former followers should abandon the movement.
At other times, he encouraged Jews to convert to Islam.
He also sometimes appeared to maintain a belief in his continuing messianic significance.
The conversion therefore created a theological crisis for his followers and an interpretive problem for historians.
Why Did Some Followers Continue Believing After His Conversion?
Most supporters eventually abandoned the movement.
But a committed minority continued to believe.
For them, Shabbetai's conversion required an explanation.
Nathan of Gaza and other Sabbatean thinkers developed interpretations that made the apparent failure part of a larger redemptive process.
The Messiah might need to descend into an alien religious world to accomplish a hidden spiritual task.
What appeared to be apostasy could therefore be understood as a stage in redemption.
Goldish connects this response to a broader pattern in the history of religious movements.
When a prophecy appears to fail, many believers leave.
But some deeply committed followers reinterpret the unexpected event in ways that preserve their faith.
Goldish discusses ideas such as occultation, in which a messianic figure disappears or remains hidden before completing a mission.
Comparable explanations appear in different forms in Christian, Muslim, and Jewish traditions.
The Sabbatean response was distinctive, but it belonged to a wider history of communities struggling to reconcile messianic expectation with apparent disappointment.
What Happened to Shabbetai Tzvi After His Conversion?
Shabbetai lived for approximately another decade.
His relationship with his former followers remained complicated.
Goldish describes letters and reports suggesting that Shabbetai did not maintain a consistent theological position.
He sometimes appeared to disagree with Nathan of Gaza's explanations of his conversion.
Eventually, Ottoman authorities sent him into exile.
He died in 1676.
Nathan of Gaza died in 1680.
But the movement did not disappear with either man's death.
For some followers, the conviction that Shabbetai had begun a redemptive process survived both his conversion and his death.
Who Were the Dönme?
One of the most remarkable consequences of Sabbateanism was the emergence of a community often called the Dönme.
After Shabbetai's conversion, some of his followers also adopted Islam.
In the early 1680s, a substantial group in Salonika converted collectively.
But according to Goldish, these converts did not necessarily intend to become ordinary members of the Muslim community.
They outwardly adopted Islam while maintaining a distinct Sabbatean religious identity.
The Dönme developed a complex history within the Ottoman Empire and, later, modern Turkey.
Following the population exchanges between Greece and Turkey in the twentieth century, many descendants of the Salonikan community relocated to Turkey.
Goldish notes that the group's history remains controversial and has attracted conspiracy theories.
Claims that major Turkish political figures were secretly Dönme should not be treated as established historical facts.
The Dönme illustrate the unusual durability of the Sabbatean movement.
A messianic movement that appeared to collapse in 1666 helped produce a distinctive community whose descendants remained identifiable centuries later.
Jacob Frank and the Later Sabbatean Movements
Sabbateanism also influenced later Jewish religious movements.
One of the most notorious figures associated with its legacy was Jacob Frank, an eighteenth-century religious leader active in Poland and surrounding regions.
Frank's movement developed radical interpretations of religious transgression.
Some followers rejected established Jewish law and participated in practices intended to overturn conventional religious boundaries.
Goldish explains that Frankism did not emerge as a simple continuation of Shabbetai Tzvi's original movement.
The relationship was historically complicated.
Nevertheless, Sabbatean ideas about hidden redemption, religious transgression, and the transformation of established law contributed to the environment in which Frankism developed.
The afterlife of Sabbateanism therefore extended far beyond the Ottoman Empire.
Did Sabbateanism Help Create Modern Judaism?
Gershom Scholem famously argued that Sabbateanism contributed to the emergence of modern Jewish religious and intellectual life.
His argument focused partly on the movement's antinomian tendencies.
By challenging the authority of established Jewish law, Sabbateanism may have helped create conditions for later religious change.
Scholem connected these developments to the Jewish Enlightenment, or Haskalah, and the emergence of modern religious reform.
But this interpretation has been heavily debated.
Goldish treats it cautiously.
He does not suggest that Sabbateanism directly produced modern Judaism.
The transformations of Jewish life were shaped by many political, intellectual, and social forces.
Nevertheless, the movement exposed weaknesses in established religious authority.
It also created lasting suspicion within Jewish communities.
Religious leaders and ordinary Jews could be accused of secretly maintaining Sabbatean beliefs.
The resulting controversies continued long after Shabbetai's death.
Even if Sabbateanism was not the direct cause of Jewish modernity, it profoundly disrupted the religious world in which later changes occurred.
Was Shabbetai Tzvi a Fraud or a Believer?
One of the most interesting questions in the interview concerns Shabbetai's own understanding of his role.
Was he deliberately deceiving his followers?
Or did he sincerely believe that he was the Messiah?
Earlier interpretations sometimes portrayed him as a charlatan.
Gershom Scholem challenged that view by reconstructing the complicated relationship between Shabbetai's personality, his changing religious convictions, and the influence of Nathan of Gaza.
Goldish argues that Shabbetai was both charismatic and unusually susceptible to the interpretations of those around him.
Nathan's prophetic authority helped transform Shabbetai's private convictions into a public messianic movement.
Once the movement expanded, Shabbetai was no longer entirely in control of what others believed about him.
His followers developed theological explanations for his actions, including explanations he may not have accepted himself.
The result is a fascinating historical paradox.
A movement centered on a supposedly all-powerful redeemer could be driven partly by people who told that redeemer what his mission actually meant.
Why the Sabbatean Movement Still Matters
The story of Shabbetai Tzvi is often presented as an extraordinary religious failure.
A man proclaimed as the Messiah converted to Islam, and the movement surrounding him appeared to collapse.
But Goldish's research reveals a more complicated history.
The movement emerged from the interaction of Jewish mysticism, political instability, religious uncertainty, and the experiences of communities living across the Ottoman and European worlds.
It spread through prophecy, personal testimony, correspondence, and charismatic religious authority.
Its apparent failure produced new theological interpretations rather than simply ending belief.
And its aftermath shaped religious controversies for generations.
Perhaps the most important lesson is that messianic movements cannot be understood through their leaders alone.
Nathan of Gaza, ordinary prophets, religious scholars, former conversos, and distant communities all helped create the meaning of Shabbetai Tzvi's messianic identity.
In the end, the movement became larger than the man at its center.
Frequently Asked Questions About Shabbetai Tzvi and Sabbateanism
1. Who was Shabbetai Tzvi?
Shabbetai Tzvi was a seventeenth-century Jewish mystic from Smyrna, in the Ottoman Empire, whose followers proclaimed him the Messiah. His movement spread rapidly in 1665–1666.
2. Was Shabbetai Tzvi considered a false messiah?
Yes. Shabbetai Tzvi is commonly described as a false messiah because his claims were not fulfilled and he converted to Islam. Some followers nevertheless continued to believe in his messianic mission.
3. How do you spell Shabbetai Tzvi?
Common English spellings include Shabbetai Tzvi, Sabbatai Zevi, Sabbatai Zvi, and Shabbatai Zvi. They refer to the same historical figure.
4. When did Shabbetai Tzvi declare himself the Messiah?
According to the history discussed by Matt Goldish, Shabbetai privately expressed messianic convictions around 1648. His movement became internationally prominent in 1665.
5. Who was Nathan of Gaza?
Nathan of Gaza was a young Jewish Kabbalist and prophet who proclaimed Shabbetai Tzvi the Messiah in 1665. His prophecies and writings were central to the movement's expansion.
6. Why was Nathan of Gaza important?
Nathan provided prophetic validation for Shabbetai's claims and developed theological explanations of his messianic mission. Goldish argues that prophetic experiences helped drive the movement's popularity.
7. What happened during Nathan of Gaza's Shavuot prophecy?
According to contemporary accounts discussed by Goldish, Nathan collapsed during a religious gathering and a voice reportedly proclaimed Shabbetai Tzvi the Messiah. Historians study these reports as evidence of the movement's prophetic culture.
8. What was the Sabbatean movement?
Sabbateanism was a Jewish messianic movement centered on Shabbetai Tzvi. It spread through prophecy, mystical teachings, correspondence, and charismatic religious authority.
9. Why did Sabbateanism become so popular?
Goldish identifies several contributing factors: religious uncertainty, uneven rabbinic authority, social upheaval, Kabbalistic expectations, rapid communication, and extraordinary prophetic experiences.
10. Was Sabbateanism connected to Kabbalah?
Yes. Kabbalistic ideas were central to the movement and helped followers interpret Shabbetai's unusual behavior and later conversion.
11. What is Jewish messianism?
Jewish messianism encompasses expectations of future redemption, often involving an anointed figure associated with King David. Its forms have varied considerably across Jewish history.
12. What does the word Messiah mean?
Messiah comes from the Hebrew mashiach, meaning 'anointed one.'
13. How did conversos influence Sabbateanism?
Some former conversos brought distinctive religious experiences and messianic expectations to the movement. Abraham Miguel Cardoso, a former converso, became an important Sabbatean thinker.
14. Who was Abraham Miguel Cardoso?
Cardoso was a Jewish religious thinker of converso background who developed interpretations of Shabbetai Tzvi's messianic role, including the significance of his conversion.
15. Why did Shabbetai Tzvi marry a Torah scroll?
Goldish discusses the episode as an example of Shabbetai's unusual religious behavior and his intense relationship with Jewish mystical and religious traditions.
16. What is antinomianism?
Antinomianism refers to rejecting, violating, or challenging established religious law. Some Sabbatean practices were interpreted as having hidden mystical significance despite violating conventional Jewish norms.
17. When did Shabbetai Tzvi convert to Islam?
He converted to Islam in 1666 after confronting Ottoman authorities.
18. Why did Shabbetai Tzvi convert to Islam?
Goldish discusses the threat of execution and the possibility of conversion as a means of survival. Shabbetai's precise motivations remain difficult to establish.
19. Did Shabbetai Tzvi continue believing he was the Messiah after converting?
His surviving statements and reported behavior were inconsistent. At times he seemed to maintain messianic convictions, while at other times he appeared to reject or reinterpret the movement.
20. Why did people continue believing in Shabbetai after his conversion?
Some followers interpreted the conversion as a necessary stage in a hidden redemptive mission rather than evidence that his messianic claims were false.
21. What is occultation in messianic religion?
Occultation refers to the concealment or disappearance of a religious redeemer who is expected to return or complete a mission. Related ideas appear in several religious traditions.
22. When did Shabbetai Tzvi die?
He died in 1676, approximately ten years after his conversion to Islam.
23. Who were the Dönme?
The Dönme were communities associated with followers of Shabbetai Tzvi who converted to Islam while retaining distinctive Sabbatean religious traditions.
24. Are there still Dönme communities?
People with Dönme ancestry and associated communal identities remain part of Turkish history and society, although present-day religious beliefs and affiliations vary.
25. Who was Jacob Frank?
Jacob Frank was an eighteenth-century religious leader whose movement developed radical teachings associated with the later legacy of Sabbateanism.
26. Did Sabbateanism influence the Jewish Enlightenment?
Gershom Scholem argued that Sabbateanism helped prepare the way for modern Jewish religious change. The thesis remains debated, and no simple causal relationship has been established.
27. What is The Sabbatean Prophets about?
Matt Goldish's book examines the prophetic experiences, religious personalities, and social conditions that fueled the Sabbatean movement. It places particular emphasis on the role of prophecy in the movement's rise.
28. Was Shabbetai Tzvi mentally ill?
Gershom Scholem interpreted historical descriptions of Shabbetai's changing behavior as evidence of bipolar disorder. Such retrospective diagnoses are inherently uncertain and cannot be medically verified.
29. Did Christians and Muslims know about Shabbetai Tzvi?
Yes. Christian observers, diplomats, ministers, and other contemporaries documented the movement. Some Christian millenarians interpreted it through their own expectations of redemption.
30. Why is Shabbetai Tzvi important in Jewish history?
His movement challenged religious authority, divided communities, inspired new mystical interpretations, and generated controversies that continued long after his death.