This post is based on the episode with Daniel Fuks who at the time of the recording was a Newton International Fellow of the British Academy at the McDonald Institute of Archaeological Research at the University of Cambridge. As a PhD candidate in the Archaeobotany Lab at Bar-Ilan University, he was the leading author of the research study that examined the rise and fall of the Byzantine Negev viticulture.
In the sixth century CE, a remarkable wine industry flourished in one of the least likely places imaginable: the Negev Desert.
Despite receiving only about 100 millimeters of rain annually, communities in the Negev Highlands cultivated vineyards, operated wine presses, and participated in an international trading network extending across the Mediterranean and beyond.
Then, during the middle of the sixth century, something changed.
The wine industry declined. The scale of production fell, and the region's connection to the Mediterranean wine trade weakened.
For a long time, historians associated the decline of wine production in the southern Levant with the Islamic conquest of the seventh century and subsequent religious restrictions on alcohol.
But archaeological evidence suggests a different chronology.
The Negev's commercial wine industry began declining decades before the Muslim conquest.
What caused it?
In this episode of The Levantini Podcast, I speak with Daniel Fuks, an archaeobotanist who was a researcher at the University of Cambridge, at the time of the episode. We spoke about a study investigating the rise and fall of Byzantine viticulture in the Negev Highlands.
Using thousands of ancient grape seeds, pottery fragments, and other archaeological evidence, Fuks and his colleagues reconstructed the development of an agricultural economy that may have been deeply dependent on Mediterranean demand.
Their research raises a fascinating possibility: a combination of climate disruption, pandemic disease, and economic contraction may have helped bring down a prosperous desert wine industry.
What Was the Byzantine Negev Wine Industry?
During the Byzantine period, approximately the fourth through seventh centuries CE, settlements in the Negev Highlands developed into substantial agricultural and economic centers.
Among the most important were Shivta, Nessana, and Elusa, known in the archaeological literature by several variant spellings.
These communities were located in a region that appears inhospitable to large-scale agriculture.
The Negev Highlands receive very little rainfall, and that rainfall is concentrated in a small number of winter storms.
Nevertheless, ancient farmers developed systems that allowed them to capture and redirect rainwater into cultivated areas.
By the Byzantine period, vineyards had become an important part of the regional economy.
The archaeological landscape includes wine presses, agricultural terraces, runoff-harvesting installations, and substantial settlement remains.
Yet for many years, scholars faced a fundamental problem.
Although wine production was clearly taking place, its scale was difficult to establish.
Was the wine intended primarily for local consumption?
Or were Negev communities producing a substantial surplus for export?
Fuks's research addresses that question by combining evidence from plant remains with the pottery used to transport wine.
What Is Archaeobotany?
Archaeobotany is the study of relationships between people and plants through archaeological evidence.
Researchers examine ancient seeds, fruits, charcoal, pollen, and other botanical remains to reconstruct past agriculture, food consumption, trade, and environments.
Fuks specializes in the identification and analysis of plant remains, particularly seeds and fruits.
Different plant species often have distinctive seed shapes, allowing archaeobotanists to identify them through morphological examination.
In the Negev study, one particularly important category of evidence was the grape pip, or grape seed.
By comparing the frequency of grape seeds with cereal grains, the researchers could investigate how the relative importance of viticulture changed over time.
This method does not directly measure the number of liters of wine produced.
Instead, it provides an archaeological indicator of changing grape cultivation and processing activity.
When combined with other evidence, however, it can reveal important economic trends.
How Did Archaeologists Reconstruct the Wine Industry from Ancient Trash?
Some of the most important evidence came from ancient garbage dumps.
The researchers excavated trash middens, or refuse mounds, associated with settlements in the Negev Highlands.
These deposits contained ash, broken pottery, food remains, seeds, bones, and other discarded material.
In the dry desert environment, many organic remains were unusually well preserved.
Fuks explained that the excavations proceeded in carefully recorded layers, often approximately 10 to 20 centimeters thick.
This allowed the researchers to associate material with different chronological phases.
Pottery specialist Tali Erickson-Gini played a crucial role in refining the dating.
Her analysis allowed the Byzantine deposits to be divided into three subperiods, alongside earlier Roman-Nabataean and later Umayyad material.
That chronological precision proved essential.
Without it, the researchers might have concluded simply that grape cultivation declined after the Islamic conquest.
Instead, they could identify a rise and decline occurring within the Byzantine period itself.
The study examined approximately 10,000 grape seeds and cereal grains from 11 trash middens.
By tracking changes in the ratio of grape pips to wheat and barley grains, the researchers identified a substantial expansion of viticulture during the Byzantine centuries, followed by a decline in the sixth century.
When Did Wine Production Begin in the Negev?
The settlements themselves predated the Byzantine period.
Their earlier history included Nabataean and Roman phases, and the region was connected to trade routes linking Petra with the Mediterranean coast.
But settlement continuity does not necessarily imply continuity in commercial wine production.
Fuks explained that the researchers had access to one Roman-Nabataean refuse deposit containing only a single grape pip compared with more than 200 cereal grains.
That is a small sample from an earlier period, so it cannot establish the complete agricultural history of the region.
Nevertheless, when considered alongside the later evidence, it suggests that large-scale viticulture developed primarily during the Byzantine period.
The industry appears to have expanded from approximately the fourth century CE.
Its rise may have reflected several interacting developments: population growth, Christian pilgrimage, military demand, and the expanding market for wine from Palestine.
How Could Farmers Grow Grapes in the Negev Desert?
One of the most remarkable aspects of Byzantine agriculture was its ability to support vineyards in an extremely dry environment.
Fuks explained that central areas of the Negev Highlands receive approximately 100 millimeters of rain annually.
That rainfall is not evenly distributed.
Much of it may arrive in just a few significant winter storms.
Ancient farmers therefore developed systems to capture runoff water.
When rain fell on the surrounding hillsides, water flowed into dry streambeds known as wadis.
Farmers constructed terraces and small dams that slowed the water and allowed it to soak into the soil.
These structures also helped trap sediment.
With sufficient water stored in the soil, farmers could cultivate grapes, cereals, and fruit trees.
The technology was not necessarily invented by the Nabataeans.
Fuks emphasized that the origins of runoff agriculture in the Negev remain debated, and comparable techniques were known elsewhere.
The distinctive achievement of the Byzantine Negev was the application of such methods to agriculture on a scale capable of supporting a commercial economy.
Why were pigeon towers important?
Water was only part of the agricultural equation.
Soil fertility mattered as well.
Fuks described archaeological evidence for pigeon towers, including remains associated with their abandonment.
Pigeon manure was valued as fertilizer, and ancient Roman agricultural writers recommended bird dung for vineyards.
The connection between pigeon towers and vineyard fertilization is therefore plausible, although the precise use of every tower cannot be established from the surviving evidence alone.
Together, water harvesting and fertilization helped make desert viticulture possible.
What Was Gaza Wine?
Gaza wine was a well-known product of the late antique Mediterranean world.
It was associated with the port of Gaza, an important center for the export of agricultural products from Palestine.
Wine transported through Gaza circulated widely.
Distinctive amphorae associated with this trade have been found across the Mediterranean and beyond, including in parts of Europe and as far east as Yemen.
These vessels are commonly called Gaza jars.
Their shape was well suited to transport.
Fuks described them as relatively tall and narrow, allowing multiple jars to be secured to pack animals for overland journeys.
Archaeological and artistic evidence illustrates how such jars could be transported by camel.
The Negev Highlands were located inland from Gaza, making the connection between desert vineyards and Mediterranean export routes an important historical question.
But there is a crucial distinction.
The researchers did not prove that all wine produced in the Negev Highlands was Gaza wine.
Fuks repeatedly emphasized that the precise identification remains unproven.
What the study demonstrates is that the expansion and decline of Negev viticulture closely corresponded with changes in pottery associated with the Gaza wine trade.
This supports the interpretation that the Negev participated in a larger commercial network.
How Did Pottery Reveal the Connection to Mediterranean Trade?
The researchers compared two major categories of pottery vessels.
The first consisted of Gaza jars: tall, relatively narrow containers suited to transporting wine.
The second consisted of shorter, wider vessels commonly described as bag-shaped jars.
Fuks used the relative frequency of these vessel types as an indicator of the settlement's involvement in regional and Mediterranean commerce.
The results were striking.
When grape cultivation and processing appeared to increase, the proportion of Gaza jars also increased.
When the grape evidence declined, the Gaza jars declined as well.
The two trends moved together.
This was important because grape seeds alone could not establish that the industry was producing wine for export.
The pottery supplied an independent line of evidence connecting agricultural activity with commercial exchange.
The combined evidence supports a rise and fall in Negev viticulture associated with Mediterranean trade.
It does not provide an exact measurement of export volume, and other scholars have challenged the scale of the proposed surplus based on wine-press capacity estimates.
Fuks argues that such calculations depend heavily on assumptions about the number of surviving presses and the amount of wine consumed locally.
The precise scale of production remains open to debate.
Why Did Byzantine Wine Production Collapse?
The most important finding concerns chronology.
The commercial wine industry appears to have expanded during the Byzantine period, reached a peak around the middle of the sixth century, and declined afterward.
That timing overlaps with several major disruptions affecting the wider Mediterranean world.
These included volcanic eruptions, climatic anomalies, the Justinianic plague, and changing economic and political conditions.
Fuks does not claim to have established a single definitive cause.
Instead, he proposes that these shocks may have reduced demand for wine and exposed vulnerabilities within an economy dependent on long-distance trade.
The decline in Negev viticulture is supported by archaeological evidence.
The relative importance of the proposed causes remains a historical interpretation.
The Climate Crisis of 536 CE
In 536 CE, a major volcanic event contributed to a period of unusually cold conditions across parts of the Northern Hemisphere.
Another major volcanic event followed several years later.
The resulting climatic disturbance affected agricultural conditions across a wide geographical area.
Historical writers described unusual atmospheric conditions, including a dimmed sun.
Fuks discussed the testimony of John of Ephesus, who described the sun's unusual appearance and the deterioration of wine quality.
But the consequences for the southern Levant remain uncertain.
A volcanic cooling event does not necessarily produce the same weather conditions everywhere.
In some regions, cooler temperatures may have contributed to drought.
Fuks suggested that the southern Levant may instead have experienced increased rainfall.
That possibility has an important implication for desert agriculture.
Could too much rain destroy a desert vineyard?
The agricultural terraces of the Negev were designed to capture episodic runoff.
But unusually intense flash floods could damage the very infrastructure that made farming possible.
Water could overwhelm terrace walls, erode cultivated soils, and destroy irrigation installations.
If destructive floods occurred repeatedly, maintaining the system might have become increasingly difficult.
Fuks presents this as a hypothesis linking climatic disruption to agricultural decline.
The study does not establish that particular sixth-century floods destroyed specific Negev vineyards.
Nevertheless, the possibility illustrates how a farming system adapted to extreme aridity could remain vulnerable to unusual rainfall patterns.
Did the Justinianic Plague Destroy the Negev Wine Trade?
The first major outbreak of the Justinianic plague began in the early 540s CE.
The disease affected parts of the Byzantine Empire and the broader Mediterranean world.
Historians continue to debate the pandemic's demographic and economic impact.
Some have argued for catastrophic mortality and widespread disruption.
Others emphasize the unevenness of the evidence and question the scale of the consequences.
Fuks does not claim that plague necessarily devastated the Negev Highlands directly.
His argument concerns the wider market.
If major urban centers experienced substantial population losses or economic disruption, demand for imported goods could have declined.
Wine was especially vulnerable if it was being purchased as a comparatively expensive product.
In times of crisis, consumers might prioritize staple foods over luxury goods.
Even a regional market contraction could have had serious consequences for producers operating at the margins of a large commercial network.
The key issue was not simply whether plague reached a particular vineyard.
It was whether the interconnected economy supporting that vineyard could continue functioning.
Was Gaza Wine a Luxury Product?
Fuks argues that Gaza wine enjoyed a strong reputation in the late antique world.
Its association with the Holy Land may have enhanced its appeal, particularly among Christian consumers.
He suggests that religious prestige, product quality, and established trade networks helped create demand.
But that demand also created vulnerability.
A product valued for its reputation and traded over long distances depended on consumers having the resources and desire to purchase it.
If economic conditions deteriorated, expensive imported wine could become less attractive.
The Negev Highlands were especially exposed because they were geographically distant from the Mediterranean ports.
Transporting wine from desert settlements to coastal markets required labor, animals, containers, and infrastructure.
A contraction in demand might therefore have affected inland producers before it affected vineyards closer to Gaza.
Fuks identifies this as a question for future research.
It is possible that coastal production continued even as more distant desert producers lost their place in the export market.
Did the Islamic Conquest End Wine Production in the Negev?
One of the clearest conclusions of the research is that the decline of the Byzantine Negev's commercial wine industry cannot simply be attributed to the Islamic conquest.
The major decline identified in the study occurred before the seventh-century Muslim conquest of the region.
Fuks emphasized that viticulture continued in parts of the Levant during the early Islamic period.
The archaeological record also indicates continued settlement at sites such as Shivta and Nessana.
However, these communities appear to have been smaller than their Byzantine predecessors.
The evidence for Umayyad-period grape cultivation is mixed.
Some deposits contain relatively high proportions of grape remains, while others do not.
What appears to have disappeared is the earlier pattern of Gaza-jar-associated Mediterranean wine commerce.
This suggests a change in the scale and organization of economic activity rather than an immediate end to grape cultivation.
The evidence therefore challenges a simple narrative in which Muslim rule and restrictions on alcohol suddenly destroyed an otherwise thriving industry.
Were the Negev Settlements Completely Abandoned?
No.
The decline of commercial viticulture should not be confused with the complete disappearance of settlement.
Fuks explained that archaeological evidence demonstrates continued occupation during the early Islamic period, particularly at Nessana and Shivta.
These communities appear to have operated on a smaller scale.
They also retained agricultural diversity.
The researchers recovered evidence of barley, wheat, grapes, and other fruit crops.
The Negev economy had not consisted exclusively of vineyards.
But the prosperity associated with commercial wine production may have supported a larger population and a more extensive settlement system.
When that export economy contracted, the region may no longer have been able to sustain the same scale of activity.
That is a different historical process from a sudden destruction or total abandonment.
Ancient Globalization and Economic Vulnerability
The most striking part of my conversation with Fuks concerned the similarities between the sixth-century crisis and modern economic disruptions.
The Byzantine Negev was part of a network connecting agricultural producers, inland transport routes, Mediterranean ports, and consumers in distant markets.
The system created opportunities for prosperity.
It also exposed producers to events occurring far beyond their own region.
A volcanic eruption could alter climatic conditions.
A pandemic could disrupt major cities and trading networks.
Political or economic instability could reduce demand for expensive imports.
A community cultivating vineyards in the desert might feel the effects of these developments even if the immediate crisis occurred hundreds or thousands of kilometers away.
Fuks described this as a form of ancient globalization, while cautioning that the term should not be understood in the modern sense of a fully worldwide economy.
The interconnected Mediterranean economy was extensive enough to transmit shocks across great distances.
That is the central historical lesson.
What Can the Collapse of Negev Viticulture Teach Us Today?
Fuks concluded our conversation by reflecting on the unpredictability of major crises.
The inhabitants of the Byzantine Negev could not have anticipated the volcanic events of the 530s or the outbreak of a major pandemic in the 540s.
They had developed sophisticated agricultural technologies and participated in a prosperous commercial economy.
But those achievements did not make them immune to sudden external disruptions.
Modern societies possess scientific tools that ancient people could not have imagined.
We can study volcanic activity, reconstruct ancient climate, identify pathogens, and analyze the DNA of archaeological grape seeds.
Yet knowledge alone does not guarantee resilience.
The challenge is whether societies can prepare for foreseeable risks and adapt when conditions change.
The Byzantine Negev offers a case study in how economic success can create dependencies that become dangerous when the wider system is disrupted.
Its wine industry may have flourished because of Mediterranean trade.
And its dependence on that trade may have contributed to its decline.
The Archaeology of an Ancient Economic Collapse
The story of Byzantine wine production in the Negev is remarkable partly because of the evidence used to reconstruct it.
Thousands of grape seeds recovered from ancient trash heaps reveal changes in agricultural activity.
Fragments of pottery connect those changes to commercial networks.
Agricultural terraces demonstrate the ingenuity required to cultivate crops in a desert.
And the chronology places the industry's decline within one of the most turbulent periods of late antiquity.
The research does not establish that climate change or plague alone caused the collapse.
But it demonstrates how archaeological science can challenge longstanding historical assumptions and illuminate the vulnerabilities of ancient economies.
A thriving desert wine industry rose within an interconnected Mediterranean world.
Then, as conditions changed, that prosperity proved difficult to sustain.
Frequently Asked Questions About Byzantine Wine Production in the Negev
1. Did the Byzantines produce wine in the Negev Desert?
Yes. Archaeological evidence from the Negev Highlands includes wine presses, agricultural installations, grape remains, and pottery associated with wine production and trade.
2. When did Byzantine wine production in the Negev flourish?
The evidence discussed by Daniel Fuks suggests that viticulture expanded from approximately the fourth century CE, reached a high point around the middle of the sixth century, and declined afterward.
3. Why did the Byzantine Negev wine industry collapse?
The exact cause remains uncertain. Fuks proposes that climatic disruption, the Justinianic plague, and changing economic conditions may have reduced demand and exposed the vulnerabilities of an export-oriented desert economy.
4. What was Gaza wine?
Gaza wine was a well-known wine product associated with the late antique port of Gaza. It was distributed through Mediterranean and other trading networks in distinctive ceramic containers.
5. Was Negev wine the same as Gaza wine?
This has not been definitively established. The archaeological evidence supports a connection between Negev viticulture and the Gaza wine trade, but it does not prove that the products were identical.
6. How far was Gaza wine traded?
Gaza jars have been found across the Mediterranean and beyond, including parts of Europe and regions as far east as Yemen.
7. What are Gaza jars?
Gaza jars are distinctive late antique ceramic amphorae associated with transporting wine and other goods. Their relatively narrow form made them suitable for transport.
8. What is a bag-shaped jar?
A bag-shaped jar is a shorter, wider ceramic vessel. Fuks compared these vessels with Gaza jars to investigate changing patterns of trade.
9. What is archaeobotany?
Archaeobotany studies ancient relationships between people and plants using archaeological remains such as seeds, fruits, pollen, and charcoal.
10. How did archaeologists study ancient wine production?
They examined grape seeds, grape-processing remains, pollen, charcoal, wine presses, and pottery. Comparing evidence across dated archaeological deposits revealed changes over time.
11. Why are ancient grape seeds important?
Grape seeds can indicate grape consumption and processing. Their relative abundance, especially when compared with cereal grains, can help researchers investigate changes in the importance of viticulture.
12. What are archaeological trash middens?
Trash middens are ancient refuse deposits containing discarded pottery, food waste, ash, plant remains, and other material. They can preserve valuable evidence about everyday life and economic activity.
13. Which Negev settlements were studied?
The research discussed in the interview focused on deposits from Shivta, Nessana, and Elusa, also known by variant spellings such as Shifta, Nitzana, and Halutza.
14. How did ancient farmers grow grapes in the Negev?
They harvested rainwater runoff using terraces and small dams in desert streambeds, allowing water to soak into cultivated soils.
15. How much rain falls in the Negev Highlands?
The central Negev Highlands discussed in the interview receive approximately 100 millimeters of rain annually, although rainfall varies geographically and from year to year.
16. Did the Nabataeans invent runoff agriculture?
The origins of runoff farming in the Negev remain debated. Comparable water-harvesting techniques existed in other regions, and the precise chronology of local development is uncertain.
17. Why did Byzantine farmers keep pigeons?
Pigeon manure was a valuable fertilizer. Fuks suggests that pigeon towers may have helped support intensive agriculture, including vineyard cultivation.
18. What happened to the climate in 536 CE?
A major volcanic event contributed to unusual atmospheric conditions and cooling across parts of the Northern Hemisphere. The effects on rainfall and agriculture differed by region.
19. Did the 536 climate event destroy Negev vineyards?
That has not been demonstrated. Fuks proposes that changes in rainfall and potentially destructive flash floods may have damaged agricultural infrastructure, but this remains a hypothesis.
20. What was the Justinianic plague?
The Justinianic plague was a pandemic that began in the early 540s CE and affected parts of the Byzantine Empire and surrounding regions.
21. Did the Justinianic plague cause the collapse of Negev wine production?
It may have contributed indirectly by disrupting populations, commerce, and demand for imported wine. The study does not establish plague as the sole or definitive cause.
22. Did the Islamic conquest end wine production in the Negev?
No. The major decline identified by the research began before the seventh-century Islamic conquest. Evidence also indicates that some viticulture continued under early Islamic rule.
23. Were Byzantine Negev settlements abandoned after the conquest?
Not entirely. Archaeological evidence demonstrates continued occupation at some settlements, although generally on a smaller scale than during their Byzantine peak.
24. Was the Negev economy dependent entirely on wine?
No. Residents also cultivated barley, wheat, and other crops. The concern is that commercial wine production may have supported additional wealth and population that became difficult to sustain when export demand declined.
25. What does the collapse of Negev wine production reveal about ancient globalization?
It demonstrates how a regional agricultural economy could benefit from long-distance trade while remaining vulnerable to distant climatic, demographic, and economic disruptions.