This post is based on the episode with Sarit Kattan-Gribbetz is an Associate Professor of Theology at Fordham University and the author of Time and Difference in Rabbinic Judaism. The book explores the rhythms of time that animated the rabbinic world of late antiquity, revealing how rabbis conceptualized time as a way of constructing difference between themselves and imperial Rome, Jews and Christians, men and women, and human and divine.
Purchase Time & Difference in Rabbinic Judaism
According to the Babylonian Talmud, God has a daily schedule.
For the first three hours, God studies Torah. For the next three, God judges the world. Then God spends three hours feeding all the creatures of creation.
And for the final three hours?
God plays with Leviathan, the enormous sea creature of biblical and rabbinic imagination.
It is a remarkable depiction of divine life. But it also raises a fascinating question: Why would the rabbis imagine an eternal, all-powerful God following a daily routine?
In this episode of The Levantini Podcast, I speak with Professor Sarit Kattan Gribetz of Fordham University, author of Time and Difference in Rabbinic Judaism, about the role of time in shaping Jewish religious identity in late antiquity.
Her book explores how the rabbis organized time to distinguish their communities from the Roman Empire, emerging Christianity, and other Jewish groups. It also examines how rabbinic texts differentiated the daily experiences of men and women, and how the rabbis imagined God's relationship to time.
At the heart of our conversation is a deceptively simple argument: time is not merely something people measure. It is something communities use to organize their lives, express their values, and define who they are.
Is Time a Universal Reality or a Human Construction?
We began our conversation with a fundamental question: What exactly is time?
Although time often seems natural and universal, Gribetz argues that the ways human beings experience and organize it are culturally specific and historically contingent.
Every society divides time into meaningful units.
We organize our lives around days, weeks, months, years, and recurring festivals. We establish calendars, develop clocks, and create expectations about when certain activities should occur.
Some divisions are closely related to natural phenomena. The day, for example, is connected to the cycle of sunlight and darkness.
But even the beginning of a day is not universally defined.
A day might begin at sunrise, sunset, or midnight.
The seven-day week is another example. Although it is now familiar throughout much of the world, it was not the only weekly cycle used in antiquity.
These distinctions are not merely technical.
The organization of time determines when people work, worship, rest, celebrate, and participate in communal life.
For the ancient rabbis, time became an especially important means of defining Jewish religious practice.
The Destruction of the Second Temple Was Also a Crisis of Time
The Roman destruction of the Jerusalem Temple in 70 CE is usually understood as a profound religious, political, and spatial catastrophe.
The central sanctuary of Jewish worship was destroyed. Jerusalem was devastated, and the Jewish community lost its most important sacrificial institution.
But Gribetz argues that the destruction also produced a crisis of time.
The Temple had been more than a sacred location.
It was a central institution around which Jewish ritual time was organized.
Daily sacrifices marked the progression of each day. Sabbath offerings distinguished the weekly day of rest. Festivals were connected to Temple rituals, and pilgrimage brought worshippers to Jerusalem at particular times of the year.
The Temple therefore provided a shared framework for organizing religious life.
Its destruction disrupted that framework.
How could Jews continue to mark sacred time without the institution that had structured so much of their ritual calendar?
The rabbis responded by preserving, adapting, and reimagining the temporal rhythms associated with the Temple.
Yet this process cannot be reconstructed as an immediate, orderly transition.
The earliest surviving major rabbinic compilation, the Mishnah, was redacted around the beginning of the third century CE, more than a century after the destruction.
As Gribetz emphasizes, the Mishnah offers retrospective accounts of earlier practices. It does not provide a straightforward record of precisely how Jewish communities reorganized their lives immediately after 70 CE.
Why Does the Mishnah Begin with the Question 'From When?'
The Mishnah opens with a question about time.
Its first word is me'ematai, meaning 'from when?'
The question concerns the evening recitation of the Shema, the declaration of devotion to God that became central to Jewish daily prayer.
When may a person begin reciting the evening Shema?
The Mishnah answers by referring to the time when priests enter to eat their terumah, or priestly food offerings.
This is striking because the Mishnah was compiled long after the Temple's destruction.
Why would a rabbinic text explain the timing of a daily prayer by invoking a priestly schedule associated with an institution that no longer stood?
Gribetz argues that this illustrates how rabbinic timekeeping remained connected to the Temple even while developing new forms of religious practice.
The rabbis were not simply abandoning the past.
They were creating a religious framework in which the rhythms of the Temple could continue to shape Jewish life without the Temple itself.
Daily prayer became one means of maintaining that continuity.
Who Controlled the Jewish Calendar?
The Jewish calendar was a subject of considerable debate even before the Temple was destroyed.
Different Jewish groups disagreed about how sacred time should be calculated.
The Dead Sea Scrolls preserve evidence of communities that followed calendrical systems different from those associated with other Jewish groups.
These disagreements concerned the proper observance of festivals, including the Day of Atonement.
But Gribetz emphasizes that the disputes involved more than astronomical calculations.
They were also arguments about authority.
Who had the right to determine when a festival began?
Who could declare the new moon?
Who could decide when a leap month was necessary?
For communities seeking to align their worship with God's will, these questions had enormous religious significance.
Celebrating a sacred festival on the wrong day could mean failing to observe the ritual at its proper divine time.
The calendar was therefore a mechanism of communal authority as well as religious coordination.
And debates over calendrical authority continued long after the Second Temple period.
How Did the Roman Empire Influence Rabbinic Timekeeping?
The rabbis developed their systems of religious time within the Roman Empire.
That context matters.
Roman political and religious life was itself organized around elaborate calendars, public festivals, and systems of timekeeping.
Julius Caesar introduced major calendrical reforms in the first century BCE, and Augustus subsequently modified the system.
Gribetz argues that the rabbis' preoccupation with calendars and precise ritual timing should be understood partly within this broader Roman environment.
Rabbinic texts frequently sought to distinguish Jewish practices from those of their Roman neighbors.
One prominent example appears in the tractate Avodah Zarah, which addresses interactions with idolatrous practices.
The rabbis instructed Jews to avoid certain commercial dealings surrounding Roman festivals.
But this created a paradox.
In order to avoid Roman holidays, Jews needed to know when those holidays occurred.
Rabbinic sources therefore preserved information about Roman festivals even while seeking to discourage Jewish participation in them.
The rabbis were simultaneously resisting aspects of Roman religious culture and participating in the Roman world's intense concern with organizing time.
Did Ancient Jews Celebrate Roman Festivals?
One of the most revealing parts of our conversation concerned the difference between rabbinic prescriptions and the behavior of Jewish communities.
Rabbinic texts frequently warn against participating in Roman religious festivals.
But such prohibitions do not prove that Jews generally avoided those celebrations.
Gribetz described evidence suggesting that some ancient Jews participated in both Jewish and Roman festivals.
She cited an example of a man whose will provided for commemorations at his tomb involving both traditions.
Participation in Roman festivals could be part of civic life, social relationships, or identification with the broader imperial community.
For some Jews, celebrating a Roman festival may not have seemed incompatible with observing Jewish holidays.
The rabbis' objections therefore reveal an attempt to establish boundaries that were not necessarily recognized by everyone.
This distinction is essential when studying ancient Judaism.
Rabbinic texts tell us what certain religious authorities wanted people to do.
They do not always tell us what all Jews actually did.
How Did Jewish and Christian Calendars Become Different?
The relationship between Judaism and Christianity is another central theme of Gribetz's book.
Early Christianity emerged within Jewish communities.
For a considerable period, the boundaries between Jewish and Christian identity were fluid, contested, and different from place to place.
Over time, however, religious authorities increasingly emphasized practices that distinguished their communities.
Gribetz argues that calendars were not simply reflections of an already completed separation.
They helped produce that separation.
Determining when to celebrate sacred days became a means of establishing distinct communal identities.
Christian authorities increasingly sought to organize Christian festivals without depending on Jewish calendrical decisions.
Meanwhile, Jewish authorities developed and defended their own systems of ritual time.
These developments were neither immediate nor uniform.
Some communities maintained overlapping practices, and different Christian groups disagreed among themselves.
Nevertheless, the creation of separate religious calendars became an important mechanism through which Jewish and Christian identities diverged.
Why Do Jews Observe Saturday and Most Christians Observe Sunday?
One of the clearest examples of religious differentiation through time concerns the weekly day of worship.
Jews and Christians both inherited a seven-day week.
That shared practice distinguished them from aspects of traditional Roman timekeeping, including the Roman eight-day market cycle.
Yet the shared week also created a challenge.
How could two communities that organized their lives around the same seven-day cycle distinguish themselves?
One increasingly important answer was the difference between the Jewish Sabbath and the Christian Lord's Day.
Jewish religious practice centered on Saturday as the Sabbath.
Most Christian communities increasingly emphasized Sunday, although practices varied and some Christians observed both days in different ways.
The distinction gained additional significance when Christianity became closely connected to imperial power.
In the early fourth century, Constantine issued legislation establishing Sunday as a day of rest for many occupations.
Gribetz suggests that this imperial promotion of Sunday provides important context for understanding the rabbis' increasing elaboration of Sabbath practices.
The weekly calendar became a means of articulating religious difference in a world where political authority was increasingly associated with Christianity.
What About the Samaritans?
The Samaritans complicate any simple division between Jews and Christians.
Like Jews, Samaritans observe the Sabbath on Saturday.
They also share important scriptural traditions with Jewish communities.
Yet their religious identity centers on Mount Gerizim rather than Jerusalem.
Rabbinic sources reveal considerable uncertainty and debate over how Samaritans should be classified.
Were they part of the Jewish community, or were they a distinct religious group?
Gribetz explained that ancient Samaritan communities were much larger and more significant than their present-day population might suggest.
Their relationship with Jewish communities also changed over time.
In some rabbinic sources, Samaritans appear relatively close to Jews. In later sources, the boundaries become more pronounced.
The Samaritan example demonstrates that religious timekeeping did not create a single division between two communities.
It helped define relationships among several overlapping religious traditions.
Groups might share a sacred day while disagreeing about how it should be observed and what it meant.
How Did the Rabbis Divide Men's and Women's Time?
One of the most important arguments in Time and Difference in Rabbinic Judaism concerns gender.
Rabbinic texts distinguished between categories of religious commandments, including positive commandments that must be performed at particular times.
Women were generally exempted from a category of positive time-bound commandments.
The daily recitation of the Shema is a prominent example.
At first glance, this might suggest that men were assigned religious schedules while women were not.
But Gribetz argues that the picture is more complicated.
Women were also expected to observe practices governed by detailed temporal requirements.
The difference was that rabbinic texts did not always describe those practices using the same category of time-bound commandments.
Prayer, Menstruation, and Gendered Daily Rituals
Gribetz compares the daily obligations assigned to men with those associated with women's bodily purity.
Men were directed toward practices such as reciting the Shema, studying Torah, and wearing phylacteries.
These activities organized the day around religious devotion and study.
Women, meanwhile, were expected to pay close attention to menstrual cycles and the requirements of purity and impurity.
This could involve counting days and examining the body at particular times.
Gribetz notes that some of these practices were scheduled at the same times of day when men were expected to recite the Shema.
The contrast is revealing.
In the rabbinic literary framework, men's religious time was frequently oriented toward prayer and Torah study, while women's time was frequently organized around bodily purity.
Both were governed by schedules.
But the rabbis assigned different religious significance to those schedules.
Gribetz argues that these distinctions helped construct gendered identities within rabbinic Judaism.
She also notes an important historical development.
After the Temple's destruction, rabbinic attention to men's bodily purity generally diminished, while the regulation of women's menstrual purity continued and became more elaborate in later sources.
The absence of the Temple changed the practical significance of some purity requirements.
Menstrual purity, however, remained connected to sexual relations and therefore continued to have consequences outside the Temple cult.
These are arguments about the patterns and priorities of rabbinic literature, not evidence that all Jewish women followed the prescribed practices in the same way.
Were Women Forbidden from Reciting the Shema?
Gribetz makes an important distinction between exemption and prohibition.
The Mishnah exempts women from the obligation to recite the Shema at its prescribed times.
That does not mean it categorically prohibits women from reciting the prayer.
A woman could recite the Shema voluntarily.
However, exemption could affect religious status because rabbinic texts often distinguished between those obligated to perform a commandment and those who performed it voluntarily.
Other practices, particularly Torah study, were subject to more restrictive interpretations in certain rabbinic sources.
Gribetz also emphasizes the limitations of the surviving evidence.
Rabbinic literature largely preserves the voices and priorities of male religious authorities.
It provides a less direct account of how women themselves understood or negotiated these obligations.
Evidence from later Jewish communities suggests that women's practices did not always correspond neatly to rabbinic expectations.
The distinction between prescribed religious time and lived religious time is therefore crucial.
What Does God Do All Day According to the Talmud?
Perhaps the most surprising part of our conversation concerned divine time.
The Babylonian Talmud, in tractate Avodah Zarah, describes a twelve-hour daily schedule for God.
According to this tradition, God spends:
The first three hours studying Torah.
The next three hours judging the world.
The following three hours sustaining and feeding creation.
The final three hours playing with Leviathan.
The schedule is striking because it imagines an eternal deity participating in the same kind of structured daily time that governs human life.
Gribetz initially encountered this passage as an unusual rabbinic curiosity.
But as she investigated, she discovered that the idea of God's schedule appeared across different forms of Jewish literature and religious practice.
Aramaic biblical translations, liturgical poetry, and other traditions imagined God engaging in recurring activities.
Some Palestinian traditions described God arranging marriages.
These were not simply isolated scholarly speculations.
They reflected broader questions about how God interacted with the world.
Why Does God Play with Leviathan?
Leviathan is a powerful sea creature known from biblical literature and later Jewish traditions.
In some rabbinic accounts, God originally creates two Leviathans, male and female.
The possibility of their reproduction threatens the stability of creation.
The female Leviathan is therefore killed, while the male survives.
Gribetz connects this tradition to the question of companionship.
In the creation story, God provides partners for living creatures.
Yet God remains without an equivalent companion.
The surviving Leviathan is also alone.
In Gribetz's interpretation, their daily play becomes a moment of companionship between two otherwise solitary beings.
The image is playful, but it also touches on serious theological themes: creation, loneliness, divine power, and the relationship between God and the creatures God sustains.
What Does God Do at Night?
The rabbinic sources are surprisingly precise about God's daytime activities.
Night is more mysterious.
Some traditions suggest that God continues divine activities without interruption.
Others imagine God singing with angels or moving through heavenly realms.
Gribetz argues that this contrast reflects a broader tension in rabbinic theology.
The rabbis present God as intimately involved in maintaining creation.
Yet they also acknowledge that important aspects of divine existence remain inaccessible to human understanding.
Night becomes a symbol of that uncertainty.
It is a period associated with darkness, danger, and the limits of human knowledge.
The rabbis could imagine God's schedule in extraordinary detail while still leaving room for divine mystery.
Can God Become Angry for Only a Moment?
Some rabbinic texts describe God becoming angry for an extraordinarily brief interval each day.
The moment is so short that human beings cannot reliably predict it.
Gribetz interprets this as another example of how the rabbis used time to express divine characteristics.
God's anger is limited rather than constant.
Yet its timing remains beyond human control.
Other sources depict God laughing, grieving, or showing mercy.
These emotions connect divine life to events in the human world.
The rabbis therefore imagine a God who is eternal and powerful but also responsive to creation.
How Can God Be Eternal and Still Follow a Schedule?
This question lies at the heart of Gribetz's study.
Some theological traditions emphasize divine eternity by imagining God as existing outside time.
Rabbinic sources often take a different approach.
They portray God as eternal but deeply engaged in temporal activity.
God's power is expressed not by escaping time, but by using it perfectly.
Every hour has a purpose.
God studies, judges, provides for creation, and sustains the world without interruption.
Gribetz compares this depiction with the carefully organized schedules of Roman elites and emperors.
In the Roman world, the ability to organize and control time could be associated with authority.
By imagining God as the ultimate timekeeper, the rabbis asserted a form of divine sovereignty that exceeded imperial power.
The schedule also offered a model for human behavior.
If God begins each day with Torah study, then Torah study becomes a priority for those seeking to imitate divine conduct.
Timekeeping was therefore both theological and pedagogical.
What Happened to God's Schedule After the Temple Was Destroyed?
The destruction of the Temple raised difficult theological questions.
Where was God when the sanctuary was destroyed?
And what happened to the divine schedule when the Temple sacrifices ceased?
Gribetz explained that rabbinic sources explored God's continuing relationship with creation in several ways.
Some traditions describe God mourning the Temple's destruction.
In one account, God seeks guidance about how to mourn.
Other sources emphasize God's continuous care for living creatures.
God's attention to creation does not cease, even in the aftermath of catastrophe.
Yet the sources also portray God as a judge.
In one tradition, God recognizes that strict justice would lead to the world's destruction and instead turns toward mercy.
The relationship between divine justice and mercy becomes another means of understanding God's involvement in history.
Gribetz does not suggest that these texts provide a single, systematic answer to the problem of suffering.
Rather, they reveal different ways the rabbis imagined God's ongoing activity within time.
Why Time Matters in the History of Judaism
One of the most compelling aspects of Gribetz's research is that it challenges us to see calendars and schedules as more than practical arrangements.
The rabbis used time to organize religious life after the loss of the Temple.
They used festivals to distinguish Jewish communities from the Roman world.
They used the Sabbath to articulate differences from emerging Christian traditions.
They used ritual schedules to construct gendered expectations.
And they imagined God's own daily activities as an expression of divine sovereignty and a model for human conduct.
These practices did not emerge in isolation.
They developed within the political, cultural, and religious environment of the Roman Empire.
The rabbis' understanding of time was shaped both by their desire to preserve Jewish traditions and by their engagement with the world around them.
The larger lesson extends beyond antiquity.
The ways we organize our days, weeks, and years reveal what we value.
Time is not simply a neutral background against which history unfolds.
It is one of the means through which communities create identity, exercise authority, and give meaning to their lives.
Frequently Asked Questions About Time in Rabbinic Judaism
1. How did ancient rabbis understand time?
Rabbinic texts organized time through daily prayers, weekly Sabbaths, annual festivals, and religious obligations. Sarit Kattan Gribetz argues that these practices helped establish communal identity and religious authority.
2. What is Time and Difference in Rabbinic Judaism about?
The book examines how rabbis used time to distinguish Jews from Romans and Christians, differentiate men and women, and describe the relationship between human and divine activity.
3. Who is Sarit Kattan Gribetz?
Sarit Kattan Gribetz is a scholar of ancient Judaism and associate professor at Fordham University whose research explores rabbinic literature, gender, religion, and time.
4. How did the destruction of the Second Temple affect Jewish timekeeping?
The destruction removed a major institution organizing daily sacrifices, Sabbaths, and festivals. Rabbinic sources subsequently preserved and adapted Temple-related temporal rhythms.
5. When was the Second Temple destroyed?
The Romans destroyed the Jerusalem Temple in 70 CE during the First Jewish–Roman War.
6. When was the Mishnah compiled?
The Mishnah was compiled around the beginning of the third century CE, although it preserves traditions associated with earlier periods.
7. Why does the Mishnah begin with the Shema?
The Mishnah begins by asking when the evening Shema may be recited, placing the timing of religious practice at the beginning of its discussion of Jewish law.
8. What does me'ematai mean?
Me'ematai is Hebrew for 'from when?' It is the opening word of the Mishnah.
9. Why did ancient Jews disagree about calendars?
Different groups disagreed about calendrical calculations, festival dates, and who possessed the authority to establish sacred time.
10. Did the Dead Sea Scrolls contain a different Jewish calendar?
Some Dead Sea Scrolls texts preserve a 364-day calendrical system that differed from other Jewish calendrical traditions.
11. How did the Roman calendar influence Judaism?
Gribetz argues that rabbinic attention to festivals, precise ritual schedules, and calendrical boundaries developed partly within the Roman Empire's broader culture of timekeeping.
12. Did ancient Jews celebrate Roman holidays?
Some evidence suggests that Jews participated in Roman civic and religious festivals, even though rabbinic authorities discouraged participation in certain celebrations.
13. Why did rabbis prohibit participation in Roman festivals?
Rabbinic authorities sought to discourage practices associated with idolatry and maintain boundaries between Jewish communities and Roman religious culture.
14. How did Jewish and Christian calendars become different?
Religious authorities increasingly developed distinct festival schedules and weekly observances, helping establish clearer boundaries between Jewish and Christian communities.
15. Why do Jews observe Saturday as the Sabbath?
The Jewish Sabbath is rooted in biblical tradition and is observed on the seventh day of the week. Rabbinic literature further elaborated its practices and significance.
16. Why do most Christians worship on Sunday?
Sunday became associated with the resurrection of Jesus and developed as the Christian Lord's Day, although early Christian observances were not uniform.
17. Did Constantine make Sunday a day of rest?
Yes. In 321 CE, Constantine issued legislation establishing Sunday as a day of rest for many occupations, with exceptions.
18. Did the Samaritans observe the Sabbath?
Yes. Samaritans observe the Sabbath on Saturday, although their religious traditions and practices differ in important ways from rabbinic Judaism.
19. What are positive time-bound commandments?
They are commandments requiring a positive action at a specified time. Rabbinic texts generally exempt women from this category, although the classification has exceptions and complexities.
20. Were women forbidden from reciting the Shema?
No. The Mishnah exempts women from the obligation, but exemption is not equivalent to a categorical prohibition against reciting the prayer.
21. How did rabbis organize women's time?
Gribetz emphasizes rabbinic expectations concerning menstrual purity, bodily examinations, and the counting of days, which created schedules different from those associated with men's prayer and Torah study.
22. What does God do all day according to the Talmud?
Babylonian Talmud Avodah Zarah 3b describes God studying Torah, judging the world, feeding creation, and playing with Leviathan during four three-hour periods.
23. Why does God play with Leviathan?
Gribetz interprets the tradition partly through creation narratives and the theme of companionship between God and the surviving Leviathan.
24. What does God do at night according to rabbinic literature?
Different traditions imagine continuing divine activity, singing with angels, or movement through heavenly realms. No single account governs all rabbinic sources.
25. Can God be eternal and still experience time?
Many rabbinic sources portray God as eternal while continually acting within time. Gribetz argues that this expresses divine sovereignty through constant care, judgment, and purposeful activity.